"Ask an impertinent question, and you're on your way to a pertinent answer." —Jacob Bronowski, The Ascent of Man
As of October 2015, my goal for this blog is to ask 101 impertinent questions.

Saturday, January 15, 2011

Data vs. Imagination

Today The New York Times carried an article that discusses some novel approaches to education reform. In one school, students are offering suggestions to teachers on how to improve their teaching. In other schools, young teachers are working together to modify their teaching styles so that their schools function more effectively. The article suggests that, as in all things, progress is most effective when people talk to one another.

The article does point up that this new approach has generated conflict between teachers and administrators. Not surprising. Bureaucracies die hard, and people with power are loathe to give it up. It's too bad that school officials lack the imagination to realize that the willingness and freedom of teachers to change is probably the only way to true education reform. Imagine the reform that could occur with the kind of leadership that encouraged teachers to work together in individual and collaborative efforts to create more effective classroom experiences for students. Just as the school in which students are teaching teachers, perhaps teachers should be given the opportunity to teach administrators.

In his Tucson speech, President Obama urged an expansion of our moral imagination. There's no better place to begin that expansion than in our schools. Education Secretary Arne Duncan should take note. Instead of his plan to amass data about student performance through Race to the Top, why doesn't Secretary Duncan expand the moral imagination of our public education system by funding programs that encourage administrators, teachers, and students to work together to solve the problems in their schools?

Monday, January 3, 2011

2011—Quest for a New Direction

When I first started teaching in 1965, I would look at older teachers waiting to retire and scoff at their constant complaints about the way our culture was changing and their unwillingness to adapt. Now that I'm pushing seventy, I find myself in a strange situation. I'm frustrated with the younger generation of educators and reformers who keep repeating the follies of the last fifty years of education reform that has turned our education system into a national disgrace. I find myself becoming grouchy and focused on the negative. And there are certainly a lot of reasons to complain.

Waiting for Superman was supposed to be the hot new film that would reveal the truths about the problems in America’s schools. Sadly, it turned out to be nothing more than an infomercial for charter schools and a sentimental portrayal of the injustice of a lottery system that determines whether a poor child will go to a good charter school or be condemned to a failing and overcrowded public school. Nothing points up the superficiality of Mr. Guggenheim's assessment of American education as his film's conclusion. The solution to the problems in our schools, he tells the viewer, is “you.”

Mr. Guggenheim now claims his purpose was merely to encourage a dialogue on education in America. His failure is evidenced by the fact that media gurus who had shown absolutely no interest in or understanding of the problems in education suddenly became experts on learning—dismissive of public school teachers and advocates for charter schools.

Meanwhile, Joel Klein, upon leaving his post as chancellor of New York City Schools, is claiming that one of the great achievements of his tenure was the closure of failing schools in favor of smaller charter schools. Unions have complained that because charter schools can reject problem students who have to go somewhere, public schools that remain open have become even more overcrowded and overburdened. While the facts show this to be true, Mr. Klein responds by saying that the real problem is a power struggle with the unions.

One of the stars of Mr. Guggenheim's film and a compatriot of Mr. Klein is Michelle Rhee, who boldly stated on the big screen that our children are getting a "crappy education." As chancellor of Washington D.C. schools, Ms. Rhee got a lot of press for firing bad teachers. It never seemed to me that she even considered the possibility that it's difficult to be a good teacher in a bad system. When I googled Ms. Rhee yesterday, most of the hits were about her upcoming wedding. While it seems petty to mention this, I do so because it seems to me that while Ms. Rhee might have been sincere in her initial desire to help children, that desire got lost in Ms. Rhee's slash-and-burn policies and image for toughness. A beautiful and intelligent woman with a gift for the sound bites, Ms. Rhee cuts a perfect media figure.

I have to admit that I'm jealous. And perhaps bitter. It's harder in this world to be heard if you happen to be a less striking, white-haired excommunicated teacher who lived through the half century of reforms that crippled our education system and finds that while, yes, children are getting a crappy education, the solution is way more complicated than firing all the "bad teachers." Ms. Rhee claimed that in her three years of teaching, she worked wonders with her students who then went on to bad teachers and lost all they'd gained. So then why doesn't she teach all the bad teachers her method so that they can all be wizards like her?

I don't know all the details of Ms. Rhee's success in her three years as a teacher. I do know that in my first three years of teaching, I was enthusiastic and inspiring, and I cared about the students with all my heart. The students responded. But it wasn't until I became an experienced teacher that I realized it was arrogance to mistake youthful spirit for skilled teaching.

During my career, I worked under four public school superintendents. Three of them came in with high flung promises, created a mess, then moved on. I also met with Al Shankar back in the sixties when he was a leader in shirtsleeves out to change the system and drumming up support for the American Federation of Teachers and challenging the establishment ideas of the National Education Association. When I was a keynote speaker at a convocation of Montana teachers in 1995, Mr. Shankar appeared on a big screen in hall of educators, right alongside the president of the National Education Association, both sporting the corporate image.

I believe that Mr. Guggenheim is a well-meaning person whose artistic credentials gave him a bigger voice than he should have had. Mr. Klein won his reputation as a United States District Attorney. Neither man knew enough about education to handle the responsibilities they were given. Ms. Rhee, for all of her prestigious credentials and confidence, shows little understanding of the complexities of the problems in our schools and none of the leadership qualities that will be required Time and opportunities were lost, money was squandered, America's education system remains a national disgrace, and millions of children continue to receive a poor education.

What I've just described is a microcosm of what's happening in our education system and what has been happening for the last fifty years. We need a new way of thinking about how we educate our children. Over the years, many excellent books have been written about the crimes of injustice in our education system. These books have not stopped the injustice or stemmed the tide of academic decline. I don't see what can be accomplished by any more complaining about the problem. Analyzing the problem won't do any good when our leaders show no indication of paying attention. Most of all, I don't want to become like the older teachers of my youth, always carping about the system.

Anything I would say in The Gullog is merely a variation oof everything I've said about education reform on my website. I hope you will take some time to review the information there. With this new year, the onset of age, and the feeling of time nipping at my heels, I'm going to continue to do what I began doing as a young teacher. I'm going to continue my quest for a better way of educating students. As my memoir Prisoner of Second Grade shows, the system never took kindly to my goals. That's no reason to quit. My new memoir The Romance of the Netartians, is the story of how I recovered from my excommunication from the teaching profession. I hope you will join me in this adventure of sand, wind, and sea that led me to the teacher I'd been waiting for all my life and showed me what's been missing from the last fifty years of education reform in America.

Friday, December 24, 2010

Happy Holidays

"Time is but the stream I go a-fishing in." ~ Henry David Thoreau

Gone fishin'—
Please come back on Monday, January 3.

Wednesday, December 22, 2010

View from the Hall

The other day I had to stop by the local high school to pick up something from an acquaintance who works in the office. As I walked down the hall, I could have been walking down the hall of any of the schools where I taught from 1965 to 1992. The world has become a very different place since 1965. Why have our schools remained virtually the same? In fact, I would say very little has changed since I started first grade in 1948.

Undoubtedly children today are more tech savvy and given more leeway in expressing their opinions. They are fearless in their downloading and social networking. But as I walked through the halls of my local school, I saw teenagers crammed into classrooms, making the grade in pretty much the same way they've been making it since I entered first grade in 1948.

When I asked students for directions, the teenagers were friendly, polite, and happy to help. They didn't seem much different from teenagers back in 1965. One thing is assuredly different. Academic standards have been in steady decline over the years. According to 1983 study, A Nation at Risk, our education system has been slipping since the late sixties, a decline I describe on my website and in my memoir.

All of this, however, is nothing new. One thing not being discussed is that those who are now teaching and administrating our schools were educated by an inferior system. The damage is perpetuating itself. Jonathan Kozol began a recent article on illiteracy by saying that one third of Americans could not read what he was about to say. Perhaps an even more disturbing fact is that far more than one third are content to allow our children to be educated by schools that don't even come close to giving them the kind of education they need and deserve.

Perhaps the education system is not failing. Yes, it's failing to educate our children. But the education system appears to be the strongest and most influential institution in the country. What else could account for the fact that every year we send our children off to schools that we know are academically inferior and increasingly dangerous places. Could it be that as a people, we're all just doing what we were taught to do in school, which is to sit down, keep quiet, and do whatever it takes to get the grade, no matter how irrelevant or absurd the assignment might be.

Nothing is going to change until we acknowledge that every education reform over the last fifty years has been based more on political expediency and fad than on the welfare of children. Perhaps the place to begin would be for teachers in one school after the other to refuse to implement polices that are not in the best interests of their students and to have parents and concerned citizens support their local teachers. For an inspiring story of what's possible, consider the stand taken by Norwegian teachers during the Nazi occupation of Norway.

Monday, December 20, 2010

Why The Caged Teacher Doesn't Sing

In The Tao of Politics, Thomas Cleary translates the lessons of the Masters of Huaninan who point out the difficulties in trying to live with virtue and intelligence in an environment polluted with the desires of the ambitious and greedy. As the masters put it, "Place a monkey in a cage, and it is the same as a pig, not because it isn't clever and quick, but because it has no place to freely exercise its capabilities."

While I take issue with the disparaging tone toward pigs, this quote is still useful in questioning the recent slash and burn philosophy adopted by some education reformers such as former Chancellor of D.C. schools, Michelle Rhee. I don't doubt Ms. Rhee's sincerity in wanting to change the way we educate children. As she so accurately put it in the recent documentary, Waiting for Superman, our children are getting a "crappy education." But chief among Ms. Rhee's plans to improve education was a full-throttle drive to get rid of all bad teachers.

Certainly, we need to weed out teachers who don't belong in the profession. Just was we should be weeding out doctors, politicians, and financiers who are harmful to our well being. However, if we look at recent international test scores, American students are seriously behind other countries and sinking lower by the year. To what extent is bad teaching the problem? In 1983, that landmark study of our education system, A Nation at Risk, warned us that our education system had been in decline since the late sixties. There is plenty of evidence to show that decline has continued unabated. This means nearly everyone now running the education system and our country was educated by a system in decline.

The list of graduates from the system include not only Michelle Rhee but President Obama, former President Bush, Education Secretary Arne Duncan, as well as most members of Congress and the presidents cabinet and advisors. The state of our schools as well as our government, health care system, financial institutions, and the environment suggests that advanced degrees from even the most prestigious universities have not imbued our leaders with the character, sense of justice, and problem-solving skills required to ensure the well being of the poor and middle class. We the People have also not learned how to demand better from our leaders.

All systems are the same system, and the system in America is not just broken; it's corrupt. At the heart of this corruption is an education system that places more importance on percentiles and winning than on character and wisdom, more importance on science and technology than the wisdom of the arts and humanities. Today in many schools, thirty thousand years of what it mean to be human have been reduced to an occasional elective.

The real problem in our schools is not bad teachers. The problem is that even the best teachers are hampered by a system created by leaders who for the last fifty years have legislated out nearly every impetus for compassion, creativity, intellectual integrity, and sound teaching methods. Could it be that if given a more just and creative system, those "bad teachers" might receive the kind of training and opportunity that would enable them to flourish.

It's the rare person who goes into teaching without wanting to teach and to make a difference in children's lives. Michelle Rhee and those who support her slash and burn policies give no evidence of understanding the history of education reform in America and why what's happening in our schools is defeating the efforts of even the best teachers.

For more on the history of education reform in America, please visit The Gulliver Initiative, and check the navigation bar for the section on the history of education reform.

Wednesday, December 15, 2010

Out Of Jail But Not Free

History shows that under totalitarian regimes, teachers and artists are among the first to go. Ideas threaten ideologues. Even in the Roman republic, military leaders marched the teachers and students from conquered nations through the streets of Rome to signify that foreign ideas were not welcome in the Empire. The writings of Russian poet Anna Akhamatova were condemned and censored by Stalinist authorities. Still, she continued to bear witness to Stalin's atrocities. Because Akhamatova was too popular among the Russian people to be imprisoned or executed, the state imprisoned members of her family who experienced deep suffering and even death.

The dictatorship in Nigeria pronounced a death sentence on Wole Soyinka for his activist writings denouncing oppression. He continued to write with his own blood after being imprisoned without a pen. Playwright Vaclav Havel spent four years in prison before becoming president of the Czech Republic. Throughout history, oppressors and apparatchiks have viewed artists and teachers as dangerous people. Not, however, in America.

In a series of lectures in the fifties, British scientist and writer C. P. Snow warned of the separation of what he called the Two Cultures. His academic friends in the sciences and humanities had stopped talking to one another. Snow said that this separation threatened to compromise life in the free world because the sciences were evolving without the wisdom of the arts and humanities.

Snow didn't oppose technology. He was concerned that while technology brought great advances in helping people, it also created a wider divide between the rich who could afford to benefit from the advances and the poor who could not. He also pointed out that while technological advancements offered great benefits, those same advancements also made a country more prepared for war. His concerns were prophetic, as we see now in our growing global crisis.

Richard Feynman, Nobel laureate in physics once said, "The theoretical broadening which comes from having many humanities subjects on the campus is offset by the dopiness of people who study these things...." It's tempting for me as one of those arts and humanities people to be offended by this statement. But I think that while the word dopiness may be too glib, Feynman was right.

A good argument can me made that since the fifties, many scholars in the arts and humanities have not made their studies relevant to our rapidly changing technological world. Neither have public-school teachers who, for the last fifty years, have acquiesced to policies they know have not been in the best interests of children.

Teachers and artists in America are not dangerous to the political establishment. Artists don't challenge the injustices, inhumanity, and rampant ambition within our government. Instead, they apply for grants and residencies within the establishment. Teachers will fight for tenure, salaries, and benefits but continue to implement policies that we all know are damaging to children and have decimated our entire education system.

Now, I don't want to see artists and teachers going to prison. On the other hand, the real promise of America is that people shouldn't have to go to prison for speaking the truth on behalf of liberty and justice for all. The problem is that the artists and teachers who should be the bearers of truth have grown too insular and comfortable and therefore irrelevant.

Hitler burned books and replaced the challenging work of German Expressionists with sentimental pageantry. Too many of our nation's teachers and artists have allowed themselves to become part of the sentimental American pageantry. Art events are a great places for networking and catching up with friends over wine and cheese. When a creative teacher is stifled or driven from the system, people just shake their heads at what we have all come not just to expect but to accept.


For more on the history of education reform in America, please visit The Gulliver Initiative.

Friday, December 10, 2010

Down the Pipeline

Albert Einstein said that when it came to science, "Imagination is more important than knowledge."

Richard Feynman, nobel laureate in physics, said, "Our imagination is stretched to the utmost, not, as in fiction, to imagine things which are not really there, but to comprehend those things which 'are' there."

Education Secretary Arne Duncan says that to compete with other nations, we must accelerate learning and improve the "pipeline" from our public schools to college. The metaphor of the pipeline, narrow and enclosed, is disturbing, given that the problems of our time will require solutions that most of us cannot even begin to imagine. Just as disturbing is the push to accelerate learning. In fact, every drive to reform education since the National Defense Act of 1958 has been to accelerate learning. These reforms have obviously failed. The reason is that they were not reforms but more of the same. So-called acceleration amounted to nothing more than piling more work on students and pushing everyone to go to college. As Secretary Duncan also mentioned, the problem is that we don't have students going to college; the problem is that they aren't graduating.

A closer look at the goal for accelerated learning was never more than to achieve some pragmatic end. In 1958, the goal was to prepare children to beat Soviets in the arms and space races. In the eighties, the focus was to prepare students for the world of business. Today, the goal is to teach children to read and to raise their test scores so that they can become competitive in the global marketplace. None of this has been about the children. Its been about achieving political and corporate ambitions. And no one is challenging this shortsighted approach to education reform. Or that such use of our children is abuse.

In response to last Friday's Gullog about the importance of reflection, I received this comment from a scientist at a national laboratory. His B.S. and Ph.D. are both in materials science and engineering:

"Perhaps something you can address in your Gullog blog is the concept that what passed as a doctoral thesis 50 years ago in chemistry is now taught in 10th grade. The sheer amount of information being pushed on youngster's minds is not sustainable. At least that's my $0.02. I was looking at the curriculum at the university from which I graduated, and I'm not sure how the students have time to learn with the volume of information they are expected to instantaneously absorb. Some students also take 6 courses a term to graduate on time. There is no way one can learn at the depth required for critical thinking under these circumstances."

By Education Secretary Duncan's own admission, the performance of American students declines the farther along they get in school. Many fall behind under the load. Many find no relevance for their lives in the increasingly standardized curriculum. But should we take pride in the academic glories of those who not only survive the load but emerge with multiple degrees from our nation's most prestigious universities? What has the load of their learning brought us?

Mr. Feynman is probably most popularly recognized for his work on the panel investigating the Challenger disaster. He famously dropped the O-ring material in a glass of ice water to show that the shuttle had been compromised by cold weather. Some people working on the shuttle had warned of this. But the push was on to reach for the stars. Lives were needlessly lost, resulting in perhaps the most important and tragic lesson taught us by the teacher-in-space program. It's one thing to imagine great achievements. But we should also have the humility and wisdom required to imagine the consequences of our actions.

Where is the vision, the humanity, the wisdom in stuffing information down the young people's throats when the problems they are suppose to solve when they grow up are caused by the ambitions and carelessness of the adults who are supposed to be nurturing those children?

Perhaps the problems in America keep escalating and compounding themselves because sending our children down the pipeline over the last fifty years has narrowed our vision as a people.