Education Secretary Arne Duncan says recent international test results are a "massive wake-up call." He describes himself as the "truth teller" whose job it is to wake us up to the facts: Our schools have a twenty-five percent dropout rate. The longer children stay in school, the worse they do. And on recent world-wide tests, American students are tenth in reading literacy, twenty-forth in math, and nineteenth in science. Mr. Duncan is the first education secretary in memory who doesn't sound like a cheerleader and has had the courage to say that we should stop chanting that we're #1 because we're not. Sadly, the truth teller's eyes are not fully open to the source of the problems in our education system. Or that he has become part of the problem.
In a December 7 forum on education, Mr. Duncan said that failure to reverse academic decline in America would result in a "national, permanent recession." He talked about needing "cradle to career" strategy for improvement. And to ensure higher graduation rates, he said, we must "fix the pipeline" from high schools to college. If language is a reflection of thought, the secretary's cradle-to-career plan suggests that those who aren't aware of the history of education reform are doomed to repeat it.
Over the last fifty years, students have been trained to win the arms and space races, then to be first in business, science, and technology. We did all that but in the process wrecked the education system. Even leaders—like Mr. Duncan with his magna cum laude Harvard degree—lack the critical thinking skills to assess the problem. We also created a nation that that is being run into the ground by corporate greed and political ambition.
It's no secret that over the last fifty years, the arts and humanities became expendable. While reading is a skill, reading well is an art that requires imagination, a point of view, and perspective. The same can be said for nurturing critical and creative thinking across the curriculum. A cradle to career curriculum lacks the soul, vision, and humanity that will inspire our children to learn and our nation to live according to the nobility of the principles it espouses.
When interviewed, Mr. Duncan rattles off his to-do list for implementing his cradle-to-career strategy: great principals, world-class teachers, longer school years, meals for hungry students, eye glasses for kids who can't see to learn. While I agree with the secretary, I also know from my teaching that the successful teacher is the one with the skill to transcend the realities of the system. We have a nation full of teachers who are struggling because they haven't received good training and are working for administrators who have been trained to keep the lid on problems instead of solving them. The slash-and-burn policies that would drive "bad" teachers and principals from schools may be shortsighted. Maybe what these teachers and administrators need is a more creative type of retraining...and the leadership to help them bring order and discipline to schools that have fallen into chaos.
I'm not sure that Secretary Duncan really understands what is happening to our children and our teachers in those pipelines to college. He is not seeing how fifty years of education reforms based on political ambitions and fads have resulted in schools where thirty thousand years of what it means to be human have been reduced to an occasional elective. He is not seeing how this narrow vision of education has stifled the spirit our children, as well as their capacity to learn, and how fifty years of this approach to education has damaged the national psyche.
"When one person cries out, 'The emperor is naked!'—when a single person breaks the rules of the game, thus exposing it as a game—everything suddenly appears in another light...." —Václav Havel , "The Power of the Powerless."
"Ask an impertinent question, and you're on your way to a pertinent answer." —Jacob Bronowski, The Ascent of Man
As of October 2015, my goal for this blog is to ask 101 impertinent questions.
Wednesday, December 8, 2010
Monday, December 6, 2010
What is Mayor Bloomberg Thinking?
Mayor Michael Bloomberg's choice for the new chancellor of New York City schools is Cathie Black. A publication executive heralded as the "First Lady of American Magazines," Ms. Black is the author of "Basic Black: The Essential Guide for Getting Ahead at Work (and in Life). Interesting that life lessons is in parentheses.
Ms. Black has no experience in education and sent her own children to a private boarding school. But Mayor Bloomberg insists she is qualified by virtue of her cost-cutting skills and her experience in customer relations. The latter, he claims, will enable her to heal the rift between teachers and parents. What she brings to education is essentially a business model.
I haven't read Ms. Black's book. The pitch for the book portrays her as "a funny mentor who understands the challenges she faces." The pitch also tauts her as one of Forbes's "100 Most Powerful Women" and among Fortune’s "50 Most Powerful Women in Business." Her book would teach me how to handle interviews, which rules to break, and why I shouldn't hold grudges. It sounds like the power of now meets everything I need to learn I learned in kindergarten. But there's a history to education reform that has led to failure, and we need to address this, not with simplistic lessons but with serious reflection as a people on how it is that with all of our country's wealth and human resources, we allowed our education system to deteriorate into a national disgrace.
But let's assume that Ms. Black will be successful in creating a model for education reform. There's still the question as to whether what she will bring to education is what we want for our children. Since the National Defense Education Act of 1958, education has been a means to an end, much like the successful business model. Schools prepared students to win the space race, to beat the Soviets in the arms race, to outdo each other in sports and test scores, to make great strides in the sciences and technology, and to excel in business. In this competitive, goal oriented environment, the arts and humanities became expendable. And so did the commitment to giving all of our children the education they need and deserve. Perhaps student achievement has declined because children are not driven by nature to achieve the goals set by those who are ambitious for wealth and power.
The language of Education Secretary Arne Duncan's Race to the Top and the Common Core State Standards for curriculum tells us that our education goals should be to prepare children to compete in the global marketplace. This sounds high minded. But I learned as a teacher that when planning lessons, I needed to imagine what children would actually be doing in the classroom during that lesson. It seems to me that goals of achieving military and economic success are better suited to fulfilling the ambitions of politicians and corporate leaders than children. Most children don't naturally respond to such cold goals. Maybe declining achievement is rooted in the resistance of our children to goals that stifle rather than nurture their growth as individuals. Maybe the apathy and dropout rate are unexpressed desires for education that broader in scope and spirit than what our schools are offering.
Ms. Black has no experience in education and sent her own children to a private boarding school. But Mayor Bloomberg insists she is qualified by virtue of her cost-cutting skills and her experience in customer relations. The latter, he claims, will enable her to heal the rift between teachers and parents. What she brings to education is essentially a business model.
I haven't read Ms. Black's book. The pitch for the book portrays her as "a funny mentor who understands the challenges she faces." The pitch also tauts her as one of Forbes's "100 Most Powerful Women" and among Fortune’s "50 Most Powerful Women in Business." Her book would teach me how to handle interviews, which rules to break, and why I shouldn't hold grudges. It sounds like the power of now meets everything I need to learn I learned in kindergarten. But there's a history to education reform that has led to failure, and we need to address this, not with simplistic lessons but with serious reflection as a people on how it is that with all of our country's wealth and human resources, we allowed our education system to deteriorate into a national disgrace.
But let's assume that Ms. Black will be successful in creating a model for education reform. There's still the question as to whether what she will bring to education is what we want for our children. Since the National Defense Education Act of 1958, education has been a means to an end, much like the successful business model. Schools prepared students to win the space race, to beat the Soviets in the arms race, to outdo each other in sports and test scores, to make great strides in the sciences and technology, and to excel in business. In this competitive, goal oriented environment, the arts and humanities became expendable. And so did the commitment to giving all of our children the education they need and deserve. Perhaps student achievement has declined because children are not driven by nature to achieve the goals set by those who are ambitious for wealth and power.
The language of Education Secretary Arne Duncan's Race to the Top and the Common Core State Standards for curriculum tells us that our education goals should be to prepare children to compete in the global marketplace. This sounds high minded. But I learned as a teacher that when planning lessons, I needed to imagine what children would actually be doing in the classroom during that lesson. It seems to me that goals of achieving military and economic success are better suited to fulfilling the ambitions of politicians and corporate leaders than children. Most children don't naturally respond to such cold goals. Maybe declining achievement is rooted in the resistance of our children to goals that stifle rather than nurture their growth as individuals. Maybe the apathy and dropout rate are unexpressed desires for education that broader in scope and spirit than what our schools are offering.
Labels:
Leadership
Friday, December 3, 2010
On the Rat Race, Reflection, and Ivan Illich
Fridays here at The Gullog will be a day of reflection.
There's not much time to reflect in school, is there? When I was first assigned to teach AP literature back in the eighties, my principal sent me to a seminar. The presenter was a gung-ho but motherly woman. Her students eight novels a month and gathered at her house one evening a week to memorize all the literary lingo from aesthetic distance (the detachment by a writer or reader from the work being written or read to ensure an objective rather than emotional response to the subject) to zeugma (the technique of yoking two words together for effect as from Gibbon's observation "laws the wily tyrant dictated and obeyed") Her students were also taking four other AP or accelerated classes.
I sat there thinking of my nephew who on the last day of his AP lit class burned his copy of Walden out of rage and hatred for the book and the oppressive demans of the class. Hearing this broke my heart. I loved my nephew and Walden and admired the transcendental qualities in both. Of course, these qualities had not fully flowered in my young nephew who would nevertheless graduate third in his class with an impressive accumulation of cross-country awards and acceptance to Carnegie Mellon University where he would major in one of those scientific fields that remains beyond the comprehension of most of us. Despite his accomplishments, it seemed to me to be a crime of the spirit that the crushing workload imposed by the system had turned what might have been a reflective encounter into just one more analytical exercise crammed between two other analytical exercises.
For all my classes, I chose depth over breadth because I wanted my students to have the opportunity to experience that magical realm of the spirit where all of the arts originate. If they did choose to join the rat race, I hoped what they gained from my class would serve as a reminder to pause from time to time to ask themselves exactly what they were rushing toward and who they would be when they got there. I was always sadly aware, and somewhat guilty, that by not driving my students to consume books and terms, I put them, the AP students especially, at a disadvantage on the standardized exams.
How do we transcend the system and put soul into the education of our children?
On the Friday of every month, I'll be tossing out thoughts on education from those who inspired me throughout my teaching career. Today, I give you the opening lines from Ivan Illich's Deschooling Society, first published in 1970:
"Many students, especially those who are poor, intuitively know what schools do for them. They school them to confuse process and substance. Once these become blurred, a new logic is assumed: the more treatment there is, the better are the results; or, escalation leads to success. The pupil is thereby "schooled" to confuse teaching with learning, grade advancement with education, a diploma with competence, and fluency with the ability to say something new. His imagination is "schooled" to accept service in place of value. Medical treatment is mistaken for health care, social work for the improvement of community life, police protection for safety, military poise for national security, the rat race for productive work...."
Next week in the spirit of Christmas, we'll have from Ivan Illich on consumer education.
And oh, one final note. My nephew, now in his thirties, did find his way back to Walden. He works at a national laboratory. We still don't understand exactly what he does, except that it includes finding more environmentally responsible ways for powering our world.
There's not much time to reflect in school, is there? When I was first assigned to teach AP literature back in the eighties, my principal sent me to a seminar. The presenter was a gung-ho but motherly woman. Her students eight novels a month and gathered at her house one evening a week to memorize all the literary lingo from aesthetic distance (the detachment by a writer or reader from the work being written or read to ensure an objective rather than emotional response to the subject) to zeugma (the technique of yoking two words together for effect as from Gibbon's observation "laws the wily tyrant dictated and obeyed") Her students were also taking four other AP or accelerated classes.
I sat there thinking of my nephew who on the last day of his AP lit class burned his copy of Walden out of rage and hatred for the book and the oppressive demans of the class. Hearing this broke my heart. I loved my nephew and Walden and admired the transcendental qualities in both. Of course, these qualities had not fully flowered in my young nephew who would nevertheless graduate third in his class with an impressive accumulation of cross-country awards and acceptance to Carnegie Mellon University where he would major in one of those scientific fields that remains beyond the comprehension of most of us. Despite his accomplishments, it seemed to me to be a crime of the spirit that the crushing workload imposed by the system had turned what might have been a reflective encounter into just one more analytical exercise crammed between two other analytical exercises.
For all my classes, I chose depth over breadth because I wanted my students to have the opportunity to experience that magical realm of the spirit where all of the arts originate. If they did choose to join the rat race, I hoped what they gained from my class would serve as a reminder to pause from time to time to ask themselves exactly what they were rushing toward and who they would be when they got there. I was always sadly aware, and somewhat guilty, that by not driving my students to consume books and terms, I put them, the AP students especially, at a disadvantage on the standardized exams.
How do we transcend the system and put soul into the education of our children?
On the Friday of every month, I'll be tossing out thoughts on education from those who inspired me throughout my teaching career. Today, I give you the opening lines from Ivan Illich's Deschooling Society, first published in 1970:
"Many students, especially those who are poor, intuitively know what schools do for them. They school them to confuse process and substance. Once these become blurred, a new logic is assumed: the more treatment there is, the better are the results; or, escalation leads to success. The pupil is thereby "schooled" to confuse teaching with learning, grade advancement with education, a diploma with competence, and fluency with the ability to say something new. His imagination is "schooled" to accept service in place of value. Medical treatment is mistaken for health care, social work for the improvement of community life, police protection for safety, military poise for national security, the rat race for productive work...."
Next week in the spirit of Christmas, we'll have from Ivan Illich on consumer education.
And oh, one final note. My nephew, now in his thirties, did find his way back to Walden. He works at a national laboratory. We still don't understand exactly what he does, except that it includes finding more environmentally responsible ways for powering our world.
Wednesday, December 1, 2010
The Fire Bombing of Sesame Street
Every 26 seconds, one of America's children drops out of school. On the November 30 PBS NewsHour, John Bridegland, CEO of Civic Enterprises discussed his organization's assessment of the problem with Margaret Warner. Warner began by announcing the good news that "the national graduation rate hit 75 percent in 2008, up from 72 percent in 2001. And the number of so-called dropout factories, high schools where fewer than 60 percent of freshmen graduate four years later, declined to 1,750 in 2008, down from some 2,000 in 2002."
According to Bridgeland, the delisted dropout schools achieved "Adequate Yearly Progress," AYP in the lingo of No Child Left Behind. Yes, it's still in effect. And we know how teachers have been complaining that NCLB has forced them to focus on teaching to the test. So does boosting the graduation rate mean that our children are better educated? A statistic that Mr. Bridgeland left out is that 50 percent of those who do graduate are not prepared for life, careers, or further schooling. Or was I being too cynical about his focus on statistics?
I checked out the Civic Enterprises website and came upon the "Civic Marshall Plan for Building a Grad Nation." A Marshall Plan? A Grad Nation? Are we talking about rebuilding Dresden following the fire bombing or learning to read on Sesame Street? It's difficult to tell as the plan sets goals to enlist community support to "combat absenteeism" and achieve "percentage point increases" in something called "promoting power," which I understand to be the power to raise graduation rates.
I can't even imagine how much money went in to the study and plan presented by Civic Enterprise. Yet, nothing in the effort addresses the quality of American education, other than to say we need to raise standards and expectations. The report does mention that 38 states have adopted the Common Core Standards. The stated goal of these standards is to prepare children to compete in the global economy. But where are the living-wage jobs in America?
Statistical analysis will not improve education. Neither will all the community support in the world. Better schools will come from more creative teaching and effective curriculum—two qualities subverted by the obsession with AYP. Moreover, there is nothing in the Civic Marshall Plan that hasn't been tried—and failed to reverse the deterioration of our education system.
The tragic reality is that our children are falling through the cracks between America's military and economic superpower status (See my history of education reform at The Gulliver Initiative). The problems in our schools reflect the way We the People have allowed politicians and corporations to shape the nation's value system. Blogs to come will explore this mindset and antidotes to it in more detail.
Meanwhile, send us examples of how your school takes the spirit of the child out of learning.
According to Bridgeland, the delisted dropout schools achieved "Adequate Yearly Progress," AYP in the lingo of No Child Left Behind. Yes, it's still in effect. And we know how teachers have been complaining that NCLB has forced them to focus on teaching to the test. So does boosting the graduation rate mean that our children are better educated? A statistic that Mr. Bridgeland left out is that 50 percent of those who do graduate are not prepared for life, careers, or further schooling. Or was I being too cynical about his focus on statistics?
I checked out the Civic Enterprises website and came upon the "Civic Marshall Plan for Building a Grad Nation." A Marshall Plan? A Grad Nation? Are we talking about rebuilding Dresden following the fire bombing or learning to read on Sesame Street? It's difficult to tell as the plan sets goals to enlist community support to "combat absenteeism" and achieve "percentage point increases" in something called "promoting power," which I understand to be the power to raise graduation rates.
I can't even imagine how much money went in to the study and plan presented by Civic Enterprise. Yet, nothing in the effort addresses the quality of American education, other than to say we need to raise standards and expectations. The report does mention that 38 states have adopted the Common Core Standards. The stated goal of these standards is to prepare children to compete in the global economy. But where are the living-wage jobs in America?
Statistical analysis will not improve education. Neither will all the community support in the world. Better schools will come from more creative teaching and effective curriculum—two qualities subverted by the obsession with AYP. Moreover, there is nothing in the Civic Marshall Plan that hasn't been tried—and failed to reverse the deterioration of our education system.
The tragic reality is that our children are falling through the cracks between America's military and economic superpower status (See my history of education reform at The Gulliver Initiative). The problems in our schools reflect the way We the People have allowed politicians and corporations to shape the nation's value system. Blogs to come will explore this mindset and antidotes to it in more detail.
Meanwhile, send us examples of how your school takes the spirit of the child out of learning.
Monday, November 29, 2010
Apologies To miner5
Following my first blog, I received this comment from a teacher, miner5.
"There was a fight in the hall over a stolen $20 mp3 player....A colleague of mine was...knocked down the stairs and trampled by students in a hurry to see the fight. The students were given a stern talking to and the next day (it was) business as usual. My friend and colleague suffered several tramas to the head, has severe headaches and vision problems." miner 5 went on to say she left that high school and took an elementary school position. She then adds, "we are in crisis mode here and I don't know how to impart this to the public." But her reason for writing was not just to lament the problems because she concludes that what resonated with her was my comment that children are not our future but our present." miner5, you are experiencing the same grief over what's happening to children that motivated me to create this website. Yet, I didn't respond to you. I'm sorry.
I myself knew a teacher who was stabbed and another who was beaten up. By the end of my career in the early nineties, most teachers I knew were so demoralized by the lack of discipline and emotional abuse from students that they suffered varying degrees of the psychological condition known as "battered teacher syndrome." Why didn't I respond to you, miner5? I created my website to promote conversation about how We the People can demand better schools. Yet I turned away from your grief and frustration and began to tell a story. Yes, the story will offer insight into what's missing from our education system. But philosophy is not reality.
You know, as I know, miner5, that no meaningful change will come to our schools until we realize as a people just how desperate the situation has become and how damaging schools are to our children. I heard you, miner5. I will continue telling my story in another blog. But I will resist the temptation to turn away from the fact that the history of violence in America's schools shows that no school is immune from the possibility of tragedy. Certainly, media reports also confirm that our children are falling behind the academic achievements of every nation in the industrialized world. But the real problem is not that our children are falling behind.
The real problem is that school administrators lack the skills and will to solve the problems in our schools. Because of this lack of leadership, teachers are not receiving the support and training they need to give our children the education they need and deserve.
Suddenly overwhelmed by the enormity of the problem and the faceless world of the blogosphere, I fled the issues and ignored your lament, miner5, for our children. It is my lament as well. Starting tomorrow, The Gullog will be back on track with The Daily Squawk about business as usual in our education system.
"There was a fight in the hall over a stolen $20 mp3 player....A colleague of mine was...knocked down the stairs and trampled by students in a hurry to see the fight. The students were given a stern talking to and the next day (it was) business as usual. My friend and colleague suffered several tramas to the head, has severe headaches and vision problems." miner 5 went on to say she left that high school and took an elementary school position. She then adds, "we are in crisis mode here and I don't know how to impart this to the public." But her reason for writing was not just to lament the problems because she concludes that what resonated with her was my comment that children are not our future but our present." miner5, you are experiencing the same grief over what's happening to children that motivated me to create this website. Yet, I didn't respond to you. I'm sorry.
I myself knew a teacher who was stabbed and another who was beaten up. By the end of my career in the early nineties, most teachers I knew were so demoralized by the lack of discipline and emotional abuse from students that they suffered varying degrees of the psychological condition known as "battered teacher syndrome." Why didn't I respond to you, miner5? I created my website to promote conversation about how We the People can demand better schools. Yet I turned away from your grief and frustration and began to tell a story. Yes, the story will offer insight into what's missing from our education system. But philosophy is not reality.
You know, as I know, miner5, that no meaningful change will come to our schools until we realize as a people just how desperate the situation has become and how damaging schools are to our children. I heard you, miner5. I will continue telling my story in another blog. But I will resist the temptation to turn away from the fact that the history of violence in America's schools shows that no school is immune from the possibility of tragedy. Certainly, media reports also confirm that our children are falling behind the academic achievements of every nation in the industrialized world. But the real problem is not that our children are falling behind.
The real problem is that school administrators lack the skills and will to solve the problems in our schools. Because of this lack of leadership, teachers are not receiving the support and training they need to give our children the education they need and deserve.
Suddenly overwhelmed by the enormity of the problem and the faceless world of the blogosphere, I fled the issues and ignored your lament, miner5, for our children. It is my lament as well. Starting tomorrow, The Gullog will be back on track with The Daily Squawk about business as usual in our education system.
Sunday, November 14, 2010
Changing Brain Lanes
The Gulliver Initiative website (www.joancutuly.com) is my left-brain analysis of why our education system has become a national disgrace. The Gullog is my right brain reflecting on the matter. It didn't start out this way. But in the midst of my third blog, I just got tired of hearing myself complain.
Starting 11/15, I invite you to follow my serial blog entitled "The Romance of the Netartians." It's the story of a shy, middle-aged urban woman who was in a serious depression after being banished from the teaching profession but then fled her lost life and broken spirit to a small unincorporated town by the sea where she found love in a most unexpected way and experienced many small but magical wonders that taught her about what's missing from education reform in America.
In your face, Reality TV!
Starting 11/15, I invite you to follow my serial blog entitled "The Romance of the Netartians." It's the story of a shy, middle-aged urban woman who was in a serious depression after being banished from the teaching profession but then fled her lost life and broken spirit to a small unincorporated town by the sea where she found love in a most unexpected way and experienced many small but magical wonders that taught her about what's missing from education reform in America.
In your face, Reality TV!
Friday, November 12, 2010
Face Time with Oleg and Henry
Yesterday I signed up for Facebook. I went with a moderately eccentric sixty-something image and suddenly felt anxious about not getting friended. What a stupid term, anyhow. Suddenly, anxiety turned to panic when the "recent activity" on my page showed that I'd changed my profile picture five times. How insecure is that! And silly, since I moved to a small rural village to avoid the social dance. Finally, I figured how to delete "recent activity." But other problems arose. I phoned a friend who friended me electronically. But she’s also coming over today to help me learn the electronic ropes. That's what friends with flesh and heart do.
Earlier in the day, I'd spent several hours with my webguy trying to master the technology of arranging my blog site. It's slow going, but I hope to have the site tidied up in the next several days.
Why am I doing this? I came here to live the contemplative life. If Thoreau were living today, would he blog? And why should anyone care what I’m barfing up in a blog about education reform? The closest we’ve got to caring about education reform as a people is Waiting for Superman—a sentimental docu-infomercial for charter schools that tugs at the heartstrings of viewers by telling the sad stories of children living without hope or opportunity. The filmmaker bashes public schools without a single word about the abdication of leadership or lack of a just and rational education policy over the last fifty years. He concludes by saying that the one-word answer to the problem is—“YOU.” Huh?
Last night I heard on the news that two assailants beat the Russian journalist and blogger Oleg Kashin more than fifty times with a metal bar. For speaking out against government policies, Kashin got his skull, jaw, and ankle smashed. His fingers were also broken and some of them torn out.
U.S. blogger Ariel Cohen wrote, “Kashin was my Facebook friend, although I don’t necessarily like his writing that much. But it was a shocker to found (sic) out that someone whose face you see online almost daily was almost murdered.” http://blog.heritage.org/2010/11/10/oleg-kashin-russian-martyr/
We don’t get our skulls broken in America, although one guy stepped on the head of a young woman dragged to the ground for protesting alongside Rand Paul’s car. More often, we get our faces laughed at or rejected. Was the Waiting for Superman filmmaker trying to say that we all need to go out on a limb to demand better schools for our children? Why didn't he point out that we've never been taught in recent years how to care for ourselves and our principles as a people?
So why do the five-hundred residents of my small town care about each other even if they aren’t best friends? Maybe living by the Pacific reminds us that tides change and that the sea and the slippery shelf offshore are unpredictable. What I learned in the ten years since moving here is what I wish I’d learned in school. Beginning Monday, I will be sharing these small-town lessons with you. Like how Mrs. Smith, the spunky Blue Swede ruled with an iron feather. And what a field of cows taught me about education reform. My hope is that the blogs may become an entertaining and provocative diversion from all that face time.
Earlier in the day, I'd spent several hours with my webguy trying to master the technology of arranging my blog site. It's slow going, but I hope to have the site tidied up in the next several days.
Why am I doing this? I came here to live the contemplative life. If Thoreau were living today, would he blog? And why should anyone care what I’m barfing up in a blog about education reform? The closest we’ve got to caring about education reform as a people is Waiting for Superman—a sentimental docu-infomercial for charter schools that tugs at the heartstrings of viewers by telling the sad stories of children living without hope or opportunity. The filmmaker bashes public schools without a single word about the abdication of leadership or lack of a just and rational education policy over the last fifty years. He concludes by saying that the one-word answer to the problem is—“YOU.” Huh?
Last night I heard on the news that two assailants beat the Russian journalist and blogger Oleg Kashin more than fifty times with a metal bar. For speaking out against government policies, Kashin got his skull, jaw, and ankle smashed. His fingers were also broken and some of them torn out.
U.S. blogger Ariel Cohen wrote, “Kashin was my Facebook friend, although I don’t necessarily like his writing that much. But it was a shocker to found (sic) out that someone whose face you see online almost daily was almost murdered.” http://blog.heritage.org/2010/11/10/oleg-kashin-russian-martyr/
We don’t get our skulls broken in America, although one guy stepped on the head of a young woman dragged to the ground for protesting alongside Rand Paul’s car. More often, we get our faces laughed at or rejected. Was the Waiting for Superman filmmaker trying to say that we all need to go out on a limb to demand better schools for our children? Why didn't he point out that we've never been taught in recent years how to care for ourselves and our principles as a people?
So why do the five-hundred residents of my small town care about each other even if they aren’t best friends? Maybe living by the Pacific reminds us that tides change and that the sea and the slippery shelf offshore are unpredictable. What I learned in the ten years since moving here is what I wish I’d learned in school. Beginning Monday, I will be sharing these small-town lessons with you. Like how Mrs. Smith, the spunky Blue Swede ruled with an iron feather. And what a field of cows taught me about education reform. My hope is that the blogs may become an entertaining and provocative diversion from all that face time.
Labels:
Saving Face
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)